As bad as 2020 has been, it’s actually been a very good year for pen releases, and I’ve managed to go for a while without a “disappointing” review. Well, here we go. I’ll start off by saying that the Sailor 1911 Compass isn’t a bad pen. It’s fine - comfortable size, decent nib, and attractive colors - but it doesn’t meet the standard of what I personally have come to expect from Sailor, especially at the $40-50 price point.
Sailor bills the 1911 Compass as an “entry level” pen, with a MSRP of $49 and an actual retail price around $39. For that, you get a colorful transparent acrylic fountain pen with what Sailor describes as a “proprietary” steel nib and clear plastic feed. To their credit, Sailor has opted to include one of their converters with the 1911 Compass, so that you don’t have to eat an additional $8 on top of the price of the pen. However, I’m still not sure that it saves the 1911 Compass as a value proposition.
I get hung up on the nib. Unfortunately for Sailor, much better stainless steel nibs exist at lower price points, and this one simply doesn’t live up to Sailor’s reputation. Platinum has the most experience with pens in this market segment, and the Platinum Plaisir, which retails for as low as $17.50, is in my experience a smoother writer. While the nib on my 1911 Compass isn’t bad, it does sit on the border between toothy and scratchy, and would lose in a head-to-head contest with the Plaisir. On the Compass, as others have noted, you definitely have to rotate the pen a bit to find a sweet spot. I did not notice any ink flow issues, however, even with relatively dry Sailor Rikyu-Cha.
Takeaways and Where to Buy
Sailor has proven in the past that they can make exceptional steel nib pens, but this isn’t one of them. Again, the Sailor 1911 Compass is a serviceable writer, and it’s even somewhat attractive, but I have a hard time envisioning a scenario where I would recommend this as an “entry level” pen for a budding fountain pen enthusiast. Typically, I try to avoid making categorical statements about whether a pen is “worth it” or not, but here it’s difficult to justify $40-50 for the Compass where there are pens with better nibs available for about half that, particularly in Platinum’s lineup. Personally, I would prefer to see Sailor focus their efforts on the $75-100 segment, with pens like the Reglus that I reviewed a couple years ago which has a completely different, luxury feel for not that much more money.
Many thanks to site sponsor Goldspot for providing this Sailor 1911 Compass for review. Goldspot carries the entire lineup of Sailor pens, including not only the 1911 Compass but also a range of exclusive editions such as the Pro Gear “British Racing Green,” one of the best-looking Sailor store exclusives that I’ve seen.
Disclaimer: This post contains links to paid sponsors, but the links are not affiliate links in that I do not earn money from referrals.